Medium 9781574414707

He Rode with Butch and Sundance: The Story of Harvey “Kid Curry” Logan

Views: 6100
Ratings: (0)

Pinned down by a posse, the wounded outlaw's companions urged him to escape through the gulch. "Don't wait for me," he replied, "I’m all in and might as well end it right here." Placing his revolver to his right temple, he pulled the trigger for the last time, thus ending the life of the notorious "Kid Curry" of the Wild Bunch. It is long past time for the publication of a well-researched, definitive biography of the infamous western outlaw Harvey Alexander Logan, better known by his alias Kid Curry. In Wyoming he became involved in rustling and eventually graduated to bank and train robbing as a member--and soon leader--of the Wild Bunch. The core members of the gang came to be Butch Cassidy, the Sundance Kid, George "Flatnose" Currie, Elzy Lay, Ben "the Tall Texan" Kilpatrick, Will Carver, and Kid Curry. Kid Curry has been portrayed as a cold-blooded killer, without any compassion or conscience and possessed of limited intelligence. Curry indeed was a dangerous man with a violent temperament, which was aggravated by alcoholic drink. However, Smokov shows that Curry's record of kills is highly exaggerated, and that he was not the blood-thirsty killer as many have claimed. Mark Smokov has researched extensively in areas significant to Curry's story and corrects the many false statements that have been written about him in the past. Curry was a cunning outlaw who planned and executed robberies on par with anything Butch Cassidy is reported to have pulled off. Smokov contends that Curry was the actual train robbing leader of the Wild Bunch--there is no concrete evidence that Cassidy ever robbed a train. He also presents new evidence that is virtually conclusive in resolving whether or not Curry was the "unknown bandit" who was killed after robbing a train near Parachute, Colorado, in 1904.

List price: $29.99

Your Price: $23.99

You Save: 20%


30 Chapters

Format Buy Remix

Chapter 1



Family Matters


arvey Alexander Logan was born to William Henry Neville and

Eliza Jane (Johnson) Logan in Richland Township, Tama County,

Iowa (not Rowan County, Kentucky, as written by some) in 1867, according to 1870 U.S. census records.1 The Logan ancestors have been traced back to Harvey’s great-grandparents James and Caroline Elizabeth Logan. James Logan was born in 1767 in Lewis County, Kentucky, and died in the same county in 1838.2 Logan descendents had been living in Fleming County, Kentucky, as early as 1795, and that is where

Harvey’s grandparents, William Logan and Elizabeth Ray Powers, were married on August 24, 1815. Elizabeth was born to Jacob Powers and

Ann (Shelton) Crosthwait on May 7, 1798.3 The Fleming County census record of 1850 shows William to have been born in 1792 in Pennsylvania. Harvey’s father and mother were both born and raised in Fleming

County, Kentucky, in the vicinity of Morehead. William Henry Neville

Logan was born in 1834 and Eliza Jane Johnson in 1838. They were married on October 5, 1856, being twenty-two and eighteen years of age respectively. Eliza Jane was the daughter of Zachariah R. Johnson and


Chapter 2



Cowboys in Montana


hether they came up the trails from Kansas City, Missouri, a starting point for the Westward Movement, or by trailing a herd from

Texas, to New Mexico, Colorado, and Wyoming, the brothers were in north-central Montana Territory by early fall of 1884.1 It is really just conjecture as to the route they took, since there are only a few cryptic references in the available literature. The latter route can be inferred in part from a statement by Pinkerton Detective Charles A. Siringo. Kid

Curry, “at an early age drifted to Texas and Colorado to become a cowboy. In 1884 he got into a ‘jackpot’ in Pueblo, Colorado, and had to hit the high places to escape the officers of the law, several bullets striking the buggy in which he made his getaway.”2 This is in reference to Harvey supposedly being involved in a brawl or shooting at a roadhouse outside of Pueblo.

Another brief mention is from A. V. “Kid Amby” Cheney who said he worked with Kid Curry as a “rep” with the Circle C outfit late in the season in 1890. “The … Curry brothers … were southern cowboys who had come north and settled on a ranch near Landusky in the Little Rockies.”3


Chapter 3



The Man from Pike County, MO


owell “Pike” Landusky and family owned a ranch on Rock Creek a few miles from the Curry brothers’ ranch. His nickname was derived from the county he hailed from in Missouri. Landusky, of

Polish-French descent, was a lanky six feet tall with exceptionally long arms. His nearly 200-pound frame possessed phenomenal strength and endurance. He had the reputation of a battler and brawler, and was famous for his volatile temper, especially when he was drinking.1

Landusky was nineteen when he left his home in Missouri to travel to the goldfields at Last Chance Gulch (Helena) and Alder Gulch (Virginia City) in Montana Territory. The River Press later reported that he took passage with several friends on the steamboat Henry Adkins to Fort

Benton. “Landusky displayed pugilistic propensities, and just before Fort

Benton was reached he and some of his associates started a melee, terrorizing the passengers.” They left the boat peacefully at Fort Benton after the captain received support from a group of vigilantes who were in town. Another account says he rode a horse all the way from St. Louis, sometimes with a wagon train, but mostly alone.2


Chapter 4



Pay Back


here was a light snowfall the morning of December 27, 1894, and the cold was keeping several men inside the Clothing Store and Saloon run by Jake Harris. Harris’ left leg had been amputated close to the hip after a gun battle with City Marshal George Treat of Great Falls in November 1891.1 He used a shotgun for a crutch if he expected any trouble in his saloon. Harris and Landusky were friends, and Landusky had put up the money for the building with the status of silent partner.

There was a counter in the back of the saloon where cheap clothing and some food items were sold. Harris had sent to Anaconda for a friend of his named Charles Annis, who went by the name Hogan, to be his clerk.

Despite being frail and tubercular, he was reputed to be a gunman. It was understood that, besides minding the store, another duty of Hogan’s was to keep the wild cowboy element, such as the Currys, in line.2

Ed Skelton, a friend of Landusky’s, was present that morning: “I met

Mr. Landusky at Jake Harris saloon about ten o’clock on the 27th day of


Chapter 5



Hiding Out and Future Associates


he Kid had many friends all over northeastern Montana who were loyal to him and he could turn to for help. In fact, in order to grubstake his departure from the Little Rockies, the Coburns of the

Circle C bought Kid Curry’s cattle and his 4T brand, and delivered the money to the hideaway.1 Curry may have been visiting the surrounding ranches when, in about January 1895, he ran into his friend Sid Willis at the mouth of the Musselshell River. Now sheriff of Valley County,

Willis was chasing three escaped convicts from the Glasgow, Montana, jail. Curry had him covered, but let him go upon learning that he was not wanted by the sheriff. Supposedly he asked Willis to extend an invitation to Chouteau County Sheriff George McLaughlin to come get him.2

Curry and Thornhill stayed at and around the hideaway for the better part of six months before Curry quit the country and Thornhill finally came in and asked for a trial.3 Robert Coburn of the Circle C put up bond for Thornhill, and he retained Donnelly and Knox for his counsel. Although some sources state that Thornhill’s case was dismissed without trial, he was actually tried and found not guilty on August 27,


Chapter 6



Kid Curry Loses Another Brother


bout the time Kid Curry left the hideaway in the Missouri Breaks and headed for Wyoming, younger brother John Curry became involved in a water rights dispute and took up with another man’s wife, not necessarily in that order.

Little Rockies pioneer Charles W. Duvall wrote that the four Curry brothers had each homesteaded their own piece of land. “The Curry ranches extended from the east boundary of the Tressler ranch down

Rock Creek which swung south, just east of the Tressler homestead. As

160 acres was all one could homestead at that time these four homesteads were only about a mile and a half long. The home which the Curry’s built and where they all lived was built near a large spring which came out of the north bank of Rock Creek and the homestead joining Dan Tressler.

The Curry home was in plain sight from the Dan Tressler home.”1

Tressler was building up his ranch, and he and his pretty young wife

Lucy seemed to be doing well. Then a romance developed between John


Chapter 7



Brave Billy Deane Dies


he killing of Johnson County Deputy Sheriff William “Billy” Deane was called murder by many people, but at least one called it selfdefense. “Bill Deane was a hired assassin,” wrote May (or Mae)

Gardner, “shooting at the Curry gang at every chance… He was as coldblooded a murderer as Tom Horn. It was kill Deane or be killed.”1 At this point in time “the Curry gang” was in reference to George Currie, since Kid Curry and supposedly Lonie were known as the “Roberts brothers” in Wyoming.

Deane, a young Texan, was hired by Sheriff Al Sproal (or Sproul) specifically to help curb the rustling activity in the county. He was considered fearless, but his plan to capture the gang from Hole-in-the-Wall by himself was pure foolishness. He rode south from Buffalo in early April and spent the night of April 12, 1897, at the Brock home in Powder River country. Deane started out the next morning headed for the KC Ranch, but first arrived at the Alfred and Sarah Grigg homestead and post office on Middle Fork, where the outlaws often stopped for their mail.2


Chapter 8



Belle Fourche Fiasco


he Castle Gate exploit was sensationalized in many newspapers of the time, and the Hole-in-the-Wall contingent was duly impressed with Butch Cassidy’s handling of the robbery. Reasoning that they should be able to do just as well as a Mormon cowboy, they decided to rob a bank. Their first choice was the bank in Dickinson, North Dakota; however, there was something about the setup they didn’t like. It was finally decided that the Butte County Bank in Belle Fourche, South

Dakota, would be an easier and more profitable target.1 Also, both Sundance and George Currie knew the area well.

Belle Fourche is situated at the confluence of the Belle Fourche and

Redwater rivers and means “beautiful fork” in French. It was a central cattle-shipping railhead for a large portion of a tri-state area (South Dakota, Wyoming, and Montana). Cowboys who had accompanied the herds would celebrate in town, spending their money freely on drinking and gambling in the many saloons, and other entertainments. Additionally, the outlaws knew the town was hosting the annual reunion of Civil


Chapter 9



Red Lodge and Capture


t is not certain whether the Belle Fourche bank robbers were in the

Hole-in-the-Wall when the famous fight occurred there between the rustlers and some invading cattlemen on July 22, 1897. The latter party consisted of twelve men, which included two Montana livestock inspectors, and was there to round up all the stolen cattle that could be found. One of the inspectors was Joe LeFors, who would later figure prominently in tracking members of the Wild Bunch.1 Bob Divine was there representing the CY, and according to Brown Waller, he had warrants in his possession for the Belle Fourche robbers.2 Waller does not cite his source for this; however, it shouldn’t be discounted since Divine stated in a January 1, 1897, letter that he wanted warrants turned over to him from Natrona County Sheriff H. L. Patton and Johnson County

Sheriff Al Sproal, in order to bring in Currie, O’Day, and other members of the Hole-in-the-Wall gang for rustling.3

During the roundup three men of the rustler clique, Al Smith, Bob


Chapter 10



Deadwood and Escape


he Deadwood Daily Pioneer-Times of September 30, 1897, reported the robbers’ arrival. Although Kid Curry and the Sundance Kid had given their names as Tom and Frank Jones in Billings, and also at their arraignment in Deadwood, the newspaper referred to them parenthetically as “the notorious Roberts brothers.” (If these two had been considered brothers all along by both the Hole-in-the-Wall residents and officers of the law, it could mean that Lonie Curry may not have been involved in any of the gang’s rustling activities or the bank robbery at Belle

Fourche.) Walter Punteney did not long persist in giving his name as

Charley Frost, eventually admitting his real identity, although the press spelled it as “Putney.” The report went on to say that all three men proclaimed innocence and insisted they didn’t know anyone named George

Currie. It had been determined that Currie split from the rest of the gang at Red Lodge.1 Wyoming rancher Robert Tisdale later reported that the outlaw was seen in central Wyoming about late October.2 Nevertheless, the posse members quickly put in a claim for the promised reward of


Chapter 11



Various Endeavors


he tri-state area, which included Wyoming, Colorado, and Utah, was experiencing increasing activity from rustlers who found sanctuary in hideouts such as Robbers Roost, Brown’s Hole, Powder

Springs, and Hole-in-the-Wall. Owing to the rising price of cattle, the problem became so great, it was reported that “The gangs have almost depopulated the ranges within 200 miles of their retreats,” with raids netting one hundred to five hundred head at a time.1 A meeting of cattlemen was held on February 15, 1898, in Rawlins, to discuss a plan of action.

It was suggested that stock detectives should be hired and a reward or bounty placed on the rustlers.2

It is difficult to trace the whereabouts and activities (criminal or otherwise) of the various outlaws that rode with the Wild Bunch in 1898.

The Pinkertons reported that Sundance spent the winter of 1897/1898 employed at the Frank Kelsey ranch, a neighbor of A. R. Reader, in the Little Snake River Valley.3 Within the January to March 1898 time frame, it has been stated that Kid Curry robbed a bank in Clifton, Arizona, in the company of Texas outlaw Ben Kilpatrick, and then to have taken a solo trip to Paris, France, with the proceeds.4 Both incidents would have to be considered as hearsay, since they cannot be backed up by contemporary news reports or any other tangible evidence. It is not known if Curry was acquainted with Kilpatrick at this time, and it also seems quite out of character for him to travel to Europe, especially at this time of his life.


Chapter 12



Train Robbers Syndicate


n March 1899, the trio reunited at Brown’s Hole and again traveled to northern Nevada, ending up in Elko.1 They checked into

Johnny Craig’s rooming house under the names Frank Bozeman,

John Hunter, and Joe Stewart. For about a week they frequented the saloons along Railroad Street, flourishing large amounts of money and breaking hundred dollar bills while gambling.2 This ostentatious display may have been part of a plan to allay suspicion from the real reason they were in town. They had made plans, probably in Brown’s Hole, to strike the Union Pacific at Wilcox, Wyoming, and needed a stake to finance the robbery.3 It was rumored that the safe in the Club Saloon contained a considerable amount of cash, and would be easier to rob than the local bank.4

It was going on midnight on Monday, April 3, 1899, when owner E.

M. James Gutridge closed up after town constable Joe Triplett had left the premises. With the safe behind the bar open, Gutridge and bartender

C. B. Nichols began counting the evening’s receipts, when Kid Curry,


Chapter 13



Finis of the Ketchum Gang


bout early May 1899, during the time Kid Curry was preparing for his strike at the Union Pacific near Wilcox, Elzy Lay gave notice to manager William French of his intention to quit his horse-breaking job at the WS Ranch near Alma, New Mexico.1 He was going to join Sam

Ketchum and Will Carver in Cimarron for their strike at the Colorado and Southern Railway near Folsom. The latter two had recently broken with Tom Ketchum owing to his brutal and erratic behavior, and were setting up camp at their Turkey Creek Canyon hideout.2

Some authors have stated that Kid Curry participated in the robbery, or at least was onsite for the later gun battle at the hideout instead of

Carver. This is easily refuted in that the Pinkertons followed Curry’s trail

(Wyoming, Utah, and Colorado) for weeks after the Wilcox robbery, well into the month of July. In addition, Bob Lee stated in a deposition to authorities after his arrest, that Curry went to visit his sister Allie in

Kansas City, Missouri, shortly after the Fourth of July (just before the


Chapter 14



The Law Closes In


reward poster issued by the Union Pacific Railroad and Pacific Express companies, dated January 12, 1900, and a Pinkerton National

Detective Agency poster dated February 23, 1900, stated there was

“satisfactory evidence” and it had been “definitely ascertained” that three of the robbers were Kid Curry, his brother Lonie, and their cousin

Bob Lee, with the $18,000 reward still in effect. By this time the Pinkertons were publicly vacillating on the issue of whether there were more than three involved. Their poster stated there may have been five or six men in the robbery.1

“In the files of the Union Pacific Railroad,” one writer states, “Harvey Logan was listed as the leader of the gang at Wilcox. What proof the UP officials had of this fact isn’t known, though it may have been because they considered him the most callous and dangerous of the Wild

Bunch.”2 Kid Curry’s leadership role should more likely be attributed to his possessing the intelligence to plan and carry out a successful train robbery.


Chapter 15



Arizona Rampage


he Pinkerton’s Denver office sent detective Frank Murray to Alma in about early March to investigate some Wilcox money that had been deposited in the Silver City bank by the storekeeper in Alma.

Murray, who was later promoted to the assistant superintendent of the

Denver office, came to the WS and questioned William French concerning Jim Lowe. When he showed French a photograph of a group of men, he recognized the only man that was sitting down as Jim Lowe. Murray then asked him if he knew that Lowe was also known as Butch Cassidy.

French replied that he did not, and in return, asked the detective if he was going to try to arrest him. Murray said he was not foolish enough to attempt to arrest Cassidy in that neighborhood without the backup of “a regiment of cavalry.” He was more interested in tracing the stolen money than running down Cassidy.1

The Alma storekeeper had told the detective earlier that a WS cowboy named Johnny Ward had spent the bills. To French’s surprise it turned out to be Little Johnny Ward instead of Big Johnny Ward, the latter he knew to be a member of the Wild Bunch. Little Johnny said he got the bills from a former WS cowboy named “McGonigal” in payment for two horses. This was Clay McGonagill, who had worked with Cassidy and Elzy Lay at the Erie Cattle Company in Arizona previous to the WS.


Chapter 16



Death of the Rustler King


latnose George Currie did not accompany Sundance and Kid Curry to southern Colorado after the Wilcox train robbery, but it was too risky to remain in the area of Hole-in-the-Wall. By December 1899 he was rustling cattle in the Green River country of Utah, and had thrown in with rustler Tom Dilley. While working for the Webster Cattle Company on Hill Creek above Thompson, Dilley had got into a fight with the manager named Fullerton, and Sam Jenkins, a cowboy. All that winter

Dilley and Currie built up a herd by blotching brands, particularly on

Webster cattle. In April 1900 Currie was caught in the act by an employee and ordered off the ranch. The man went for the authorities after

Currie warned him off with his six-gun.1

Grand County Sheriff Jesse M. Tyler and Uintah County Sheriff

William Preece combined posses, and set out to capture the rustler or rustlers. They discovered a deserted camp not far from the McPherson

Ranch on the Green River. The posse searched through the hills until, about noon the next day, they came upon Currie on foot, looking for some stray horses. He answered the command to surrender by firing at the posse with his Winchester and retreating toward the Green River. He reached the river by dark, and either swam across or built a crude raft for the purpose. The morning of April 17 found Currie settled among some boulders on a hill near the river, ready for a siege. Sheriff Preece and his men tried to pick off the outlaw from across the river, while Sheriff


Chapter 17



The Tipton Train Robbery


n August 1900, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid were sighted in the region of Baggs and Dixon, Wyoming.1 They and other Wild

Bunch members had many friends among the residents in the Little

Snake River Valley area of southern Wyoming and northern Colorado.

These included Mike Dunbar, John P. “Jack” Ryan, Jim Hanson, Bert

Charter, Jim Ferguson, Chippy Reid, Sam Green, Charles F. Tucker, and

Robert McIntosh. Consequently, they were all under surveillance from agents of the Pinkerton Detective Agency.2 Ferguson and Ryan both played important parts in helping the gang prepare for the strike on the

Union Pacific near the small railroad town of Tipton, Wyoming. Jack

Ryan owned a saloon in Rawlins, while Jim Ferguson had a ranch on the

Little Snake River near Dixon.3 Bert Charter tended bar for Ryan, and was a good friend of “Harry Alonzo,” the Sundance Kid. They had both ridden for Ora Haley’s Two Bar and A. R. Reader, and Charter said that

“Harry was an extra good cowboy with a wonderful personality.” Charter was probably introduced to Cassidy through Sundance.4


Chapter 18



Hiding in Plain Sight


ill Carver may have been in a hurry to get to Texas because he wanted to see his girlfriend, Laura Bullion, whom he had promised to marry. Laura was born in Washington County, Arkansas, in October 1876. When her father died in 1881, Laura’s mother moved her three children to their maternal grandparents’ Dove Creek ranch near Knickerbocker, Texas. Laura reportedly left home not long after her mother died in 1891, and it is believed that she worked as a prostitute in

San Antonio, possibly at Fannie Porter’s Sporting House. It is known that she returned to the Knickerbocker area for visits and to attend dances over the next few years. Will had been married to Laura’s aunt, Viana Byler, for less than six months when she died of pregnancy complications on July 22, 1892. He was devastated by her death, and it is said he began courting her niece because she greatly resembled Viana. He had left

Laura in San Antonio before going off to rob the bank in Winnemucca.1

However, Will forgot all about Laura when he met a girl named Callie May Hunt in October 1900 at the San Antonio Fairground’s annual


Load more


Print Book

Format name
File size
2.73 MB
Read aloud
Format name
Read aloud
In metadata
In metadata
File size
In metadata